Would you kill the big guy?

I’ve been listening to the World Service quite a lot of late and I have to say I’m really taken with one of their programme trails. It’s a poem which poses two ethical conundrums for the listeners to consider before pointing them towards a two-part documentary called ‘Would you kill the big guy?’. It’s not often a radio trail moves me to Google something, but the poem was so interesting and well-delivered that I wanted to know who had written it. I later found out that it was actually the promo producer Ben Motley that penned it, inspired by W.H. Auden’s ‘The Night Mail’, whose meter reflects the rhythm of an old steam train on the tracks.

The mix of words (beautifully read by Nigel Carrington) and the music make this into a fantastically engaging 45 seconds of audio – I suggest you take a listen. It’s a very good radio promo:

BBC World Service Trail: Would you kill the big guy?

The text of the poem is here, in case you can’t:

Here comes a train and it’s out of control

Blasting its whistle and belching out coal

Up ahead there are five people tied to the track

It’s going too fast and there’s no turning back

A flick of a switch and the train will divert

to a line where the five people will not get hurt

But there’s one person already tied to that line

So do you flick the switch, or do you decline?

Now you are standing upon a footbridge,

As another train heads towards certain carnage

Five people tied up – but you have a plan

Beside you is standing a very large man.

If you push the man onto the track down below

His massive bulk will cause the engine to slow

You’ll save five lives but the large man will die

So the question is: would you kill the big guy?

I listened to the first of the two programmes this morning and was fascinated to hear that for the first situation, it doesn’t matter where you are in the world, even children tend to opt to take the action which kills one person rather than five, but when it comes to pushing someone off the bridge, the majority of people wouldn’t do it, despite the chance to achieve the same final outcome of saving more people. According to the programme, research has shown that if you were to introduce a button and a trap-door into the second situation, so that you didn’t have to use your own muscular power to push the big guy in front of the train, the ratios change again, and people are more likely to take the action that results in the untimely death of the big guy.

Another situation they consider in the programme was that of a doctor who has five patients who need organ transplants, and a healthy patient comes to see the doctor. Should the doctor sacrifice one patient in order to save the others? It was interesting hearing the children’s thoughts on this, as they struggled with balancing the number of lives saved versus their innate notion that killing someone was wrong. Most agreed that it would not be right to kill the healthy patient in order to save the five others, but it made for a good discussion.

I’m interested to see what the second programme will have to offer – be sure to look out for it in the maze of BBC World Service schedules, or take the easy way out and find it on iPlayer next week!

3 thoughts on “Would you kill the big guy?

  1. love the promo too, however it would sound better if they had opted for the politically incorrect ‘fat guy’…part of the moral conundrum is that obese people are seen to be less deserving of life since they are judged to be deliberately choosing an unhealthy lifestyle…

  2. If you’re in the UK, you can hear part two on Wednesday 19th May at 0906, 1206, 1506 and 2006 BST. :) Or 0106 Thursday. Or, as you so rightly say, on BBC iPlayer. Making the Unmissable Unmissable.

  3. I live in Singapore and too was moved by the sheer brilliance and beauty of the trail — and, like you, was moved to Google for this. Your blog is a godsend — thank you for the fascinating information and the sound file. I teach English and linguistics to teachers, and may use this in a lesson or two.

Any thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.